It's just this little chromium switch, here... (derspatchel) wrote,
It's just this little chromium switch, here...

(+1, STFU)

Some dude is whining over on Orkut's IF community that games should all be open-source and anyone should be able to rewrite a game that someone else made (hey I hated how the girl in Photopia died, I'll just change the game and keep her alive) and so we can all dance happily around RMS' maypole and blah blah blah. Actually, the only argument he's made towards copylefting game source is that it "...would allow the inclusion of more IFs in Linux distros." You'll pardon me if my epiphany, then, has yet to arrive.

So I got kinda snippy. I had to edit my response a few times, mostly to get my response down under the arbitrary 2048-character limit Orkut has placed on messages, and also to remove key incendiary phrases like "smack you in the mouth", "go back to Slashdork" and "PS: I have touched a real, live woman." And I came up with this:
Want to read the source? There are a few decompilers out there that you can use on the story file that'll help.

Want to modify someone else's game? I would say that decision is up to the individual authors themselves, but the general consensus seems to be "not bloody likely." Or maybe even just "write your own damn game."

And for good reason, look -- one-half of the term interactive fiction is the word "fiction." Good IF games are not just bits of code, but good stories. Stories that an author has worked long and hard to plot and write, stories involving characters that an author has had to develop, stories crafted and pieced together in what is often a very intensely personal project.

What, then, gives you, me, anyone the right to take an IF game someone else has written, a story that someone has personally invested so much time and energy into, and say "Well, I didn't like this part of the story, and I thought the ending should be happy, and maybe there should be some sexy parts, so I'll change it to something better"? Do you think the author would be happy that you did? Would you dare do the same to your favorite novel, comic book, or screenplay? Do you think people would care to read your version? (Well, hell, they wouldn't have to care, you could just put it up on the Internet and call it "fanfic", a lot of kids already do.)

Or would you rather just take some ideas and characters of your own and write your own game? Go ahead and do that, and GPL it while you're at it, and be happy with it and what people do to it. There could very well be a nice collaborative project that'd come out of such a thing, but for the most part, IF writing is a very personal venture. And let's face it: not every piece of code needs to be open-source. I may be the author of a few silly frippery one-joke games, but the work is my own and if I felt they'd needed third-party rewrites, I'd ask for them.

Recent Posts from This Journal

  • Housemoving

    Along with many others, I am in the process of switching journalthings over to Dreamwidth due to the new ToS here at ЛЖ. I won't be deleting the…

  • if you want to end Trump and stuff you gotta sing loud

    This song is called Alice's Restaurant It's about Alice And the restaurant But Alice's Restaurant is not the name of the restaurant, that's just the…

  • o this is an existing place

    It's been a year since I posted anything and over a year since I wrote of anything substantive, but: Hello

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded