August 14th, 2014
|11:45 pm - "Help, it's the police"|
When I was a kid, my small rural town had two or three police officers and we knew each one. The daughter of one was in my elementary school class. Our family was friends with the family of an Amherst officer; we played with their kids a lot. My stepfather is a retired officer in both the Amherst Town and Amherst College police departments. We know these people. We love them. We know they're looking out for everybody's safety, even when we get hassled a bit (my father joked that once I learned to drive, he wanted to let the police know so they could flash their lights behind me and then wave--it never happened.) We are or were in small towns, however. The personal connections are strongest there, and yet I know there are professional codes that exist, a bond between coworkers which must be maintained.
My father, who was a volunteer firefighter and EMT, once told me that debriefings back at the station were often full of the most incredibly black humor pertaining to the calls they were just on, jokes as black as the coffee everyone drank while they made hideous remarks that could never and would never go beyond those fake wood panelled office walls. He never told me a single one; I never wanted to know. It was all stress relief, laughter, a much-needed valve because the demands of the job and the sights one sees and the dangers one faces can be horrific indeed. The lingo I do know the EMTs and ER workers share is cynical though humorous and never cruel or dismissive: "frequent fliers"; the abbreviation SOCMOB which stands for Standing On Corner Minding Own Business which is what nearly everybody who comes in beat up claims they were doing; and the ever-popular FDGB: Fall Down Go Boom. But the private stuff stays private and that's how it should be. It helps them and them only.
I do not know if the Ferguson police consider what they are doing as venting. I should certainly hope not. But it feels to me that their continued actions are indeed a lashing-out, a venting of pent-up frustrations and dark anticipatory wishes which go beyond just wanting to have a try at all that fancy military equipment they got from the government.
I am of two minds of the cops' "Thin Blue Line" standard, their own omerta, whether you assert it exists or not. I respect a professional's right to silence in many cases: the rescue worker's right to vent their demons by themselves with dark humor, the doctor's right to keep doctor-patient confidentiality, the police's right to stay appropriately silent when giving out information would actively compromise a current investigation, notify fugitives of their actions, etc. But I cannot respect or condone anyone staying silent to hide, deny, cover up or otherwise ignore knowledge or involvement in illegal actions--and let's face it, shooting an unarmed man in the back and then several times again when he turns around with his hands up in surrender is straight-up cold-blooded murder, plain and simple, no "he/we both reached for the gun" bullshit.
The officer had plenty of time, as Michael Brown ran and even turned back, to assess his situation, stand down, and choose an alternate course of action. That he did not is the problem. If it turns out that he had panicked and/or involuntarily violently reacted in the face of an assault perceived or otherwise, which is a completely legitimate scenario, then he needs to be taken immediately off the force pending investigation given some serious counseling before, during and after the criminal trial. Something ain't right and they need to address it. If, on the other hand, the officer straight up gave no fucks, then he needs to be given the banhammer, no paid suspension, and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law under each crime committed, hate, first-degree and otherwise. As one often hears from justice-minded citizens, "Don't do the crime if you can't do the time". Here are some crimes, St. Louis. Let's find some time.
But the real problem isn't that this is happening right now in Ferguson. The real problem is that it's happening all over the country and it has been happening; only the current spate of news coverage makes it seem surprising. Yet every time it happens the issue seems to just die out. A current joke floating around Twitter right now how the three big news networks are covering the week's events: MSNBC's headline would say "Police fire tear gas into crowd", Fox News reports "Authorities bravely holding back rioters", and CNN is going "Seriously, guys, where is that plane?" This is a form of humor last seen prevalent in the Czech Republic and other parts of Eastern Europe pre and post-Soviet breakup. I am glad to see it still exists; unhappy that it has to right now.
And when there is coverage, it's often completely and horribly twisted: Today's print edition of the New York Post has a headline in 96-frickin-point bold which simply reads "COPS RIGHT". (DOWN UP. WAR EURASIA ALWAYS.) The headline tops a story about New York Mayor de Blasio, a man with an ugly name and an even uglier attitude, telling New Yorkers that when it's time for their arrest, which he makes out to seem almost as commonplace and to be as expected as muggings were in the worst part of the 1970s, that they shouldn't resist and instead just lie back and think of Brooklyn. I'm copying the relevant quotes here so as to not give the NY Post the benefit of any clicks or Facebook data. You can go to nypost dot com if you wish.
"When a police officer comes to the decision that it’s time to arrest someone, that individual is obligated to submit to arrest..."Ah, yes, this would be the same New York City court system where, in 2011, the nice lady on the other end of the police-run taxi complaint line told me that cases such as ones where a taxi driver ripped off his passengers, say, would take at least nine months to over a year to be heard, and even then both litigants needed to be personally present at the hearing. This meant, for out-of-towners at least, that if you chose to press charges you'd either spend time and money getting back to NYC only to find that the other guy just plain didn't show up, or you both don't bother to show up and the case gets thrown out. And all for twenty lousy dollars. So you'll pardon me, then, when I say that I'm not exactly confident by de Blasio's claims that if New Yorkers behave like good little doobees when the handcuffs come out, their case will be heard quickly and efficiently.
and"Arrest is not always the goal . . . but once an officer has decided that arrest is necessary, every New Yorker should agree to do what they need to do as a citizen and respect the police officer and follow their guidance. And then there is a thorough due-process system thereafter..."
The mayor, by the way, was responding to comments made by his police commissioner, Bill Bratton, who is a piece of work himself. Bratton recently about "...a number of individuals just failing to understand that you must submit to an arrest, that you cannot resist it," which puts me in the frame of mind of the government official in Terry Gilliam's Brazil who talked about how "a ruthless minority of people seem to have forgotten old-fashioned virtues" and how if only those people would just play the game...
The two weren't talking about the Ferguson police state, either; they were actually discussing the earlier case of Eric Garner, the Staten Island man who recently died when police locked him in a chokehold. All over selling loose cigarettes on a stoop. I can't see any conceivable way in which that was justified. I don't care if he was mentally ill or they'd had problems with him the past or if they thought he was lying when he called out for help; you just don't kill someone over loosies. I can't believe I have to type that out. de Blasio's response is inconceivable and reprehensible. As far as the Worst New York Mayor Race goes, de Blasio is currently neck-and-neck with Jimmy Walker, both trying to gain on John Lindsay. I sure hope we don't go that far.
I was brought up, among the police I knew, to think for myself while respecting the law. The law could and should be questioned, but respectfully. The ability to stand up and say "Okay, but--" without fear of reprisal is a fundamental human right. So is the ability to say "I would like to know how/why/what..." when things personally affect you. Peaceful assembly, that's cool, too.
However, when it comes to sides and one or both break their inherent promise, things get ugly. The Ferguson PD is ugly. What they're doing is ugly. Michael Brown's death was ugly. The break-up of the peaceful protest was ugly. The subsequent looting and escalation was ugly. Eric Garner's death and the laissez-faire reactions from New York officials are all ugly. Ugly, ugly, ugly.
Somewhere along the line the police turned from the people we knew and grew up with to a nameless, often-faceless force which couldn't care less about you even while they claim it's for your safety. I understand inherent mistrust; mistrust or at least skepticism seems justifiable. But there's also fear, which there shouldn't be. But there sure is.
Eight years ago I was awakened in the middle of the night by three Somerville police officers pointing flashlights and weapons in my face. They had received a call which Verizon had erroneously traced to my house; somebody claiming they had weapons and were going to either hurt themselves or someone else, I don't know. I honestly don't know the details of the call beyond that. Once the police realized they were indeed in the wrong house and neither the naked man they just scared out of bed, nor his cat, nor his other housemates were about to commit a crime, they turned off the tough guy act. They stayed police-professional, true to duty, even as they explained to us just why and how they had broken into our home (they broke in through our back kitchen door after trying the doorbell; we were all on the third floor sleeping in closed-off rooms with fans on) and that if we wanted, we could try to request reimbursement from the City of Somerville for our kitchen door, broken beyond repair, but "good luck with that". They didn't give names or badge numbers (honestly I think we were still so shocked we forgot to ask), they assured us the "full report" of all they had done would be available to view in a few weeks, and then they left us without so much as an apology.
The police never apologize.
That incident was the start of a lot of changes in my life, some good and some bad, many of which still affect me to this day. I'm not including it in this piece as an ego signal boost, neither as a message of "Oh I totally understand what the people of Ferguson are going through because look what happened to me me me" nor a message of "gee if a white middle-class guy can't be safe around cops, who can?" because honestly those are both crass as all hell. What I'm saying is that something has happened in America--let's not quibble when, it's happened--which should give us all considerable worry about the handling of authority, enough to find ways to stop it or at least make sure those who deserve justice get it. The cops who busted in on us in 2006 were Regular Guys. They had names, families, houses nearby, facial hair. They were doing what they considered to be their job. They backed off when they realized their error, which to be fair was the appropriate response. Maybe they laughed about it after their shift, maybe they just forgot it in all the paperwork. They've gone on with their lives and I certainly don't wish them any ill nor do I seek damages this long after the fact. They got it out of their system first; I'm still working on it though time does help mellow the memories. The emotions mellow much slower. Still, I can't begrudge them anything-- but I can no longer trust them.
And losing trust in local law enforcement is a terrifying outcome indeed.
This is wonderfully written, Spatch. Do you mind if I share it around?
Thank you so, so much for putting your words to this issue. <3
The post is unlocked; please share as you see fit. Thank you.
I asked because some of my links get reshared quite a lot, and I wasn't sure how much extra traffic you could handle. But, I think this is really well written and worth sharing/reading. *hugs*
It's LJ's bandwidth; at least my host isn't serving tons of pictures or cat rave sounds in this entry. Yay!
I'm so glad you're white Spatch. Because I value your presence in my life, and it would have been sad if you had been shot that night. I'm sorry for all the people who have lost people under similar circumstances because they had darker skin than yours.
|Date:||August 15th, 2014 01:54 pm (UTC)|| |
Every time something happens to a white person I think "THIS is what black people have been trying to tell us, over and over and over and over".
I cannot honestly say I was thankful that evening for being white. I was quite aware afterwards of my white privilege, however, which made me so very keenly aware that there are far too many in this country who do not get it that easy when it comes to institutionalized racism. That's gotta change goddammit.
I should repost the story about my coworker from ten years ago. It's locked under a filter because I used his real name, but I can repost it with pseudonyms. An elderly black gentleman who worked a call center with me had a breakdown over the murder of his daughter, and the all-white management canned him for missing 3 days of work. All without even sitting down and talking to him, actually talking and listening. Without giving him a second chance, and he'd had an absolutely spotless record before. It was, frankly, fucking reprehensible and unforgivable and immediately motivated me to find another job and get the hell out myself. But my friend told me as he left for his final meeting (someone else later came by and silently cleaned his desk out) that no matter what they did he was going to walk out with his head held high, and as far as I know that's just what he did.
Edited at 2014-08-15 02:15 pm (UTC)
|Date:||August 15th, 2014 02:38 pm (UTC)|| |
I remember that story, now you mention it.
|Date:||August 15th, 2014 02:38 pm (UTC)|| |
The humanity of the police is where it all comes from. The bad and the good. It's possible to characterise the idea that police action shouldn't be brutal as an expression of another idea, that police aren't human, that all cops are bastards in the sense that all cops are subhuman scum. But that would be a mistake – a human mistake. As you set out right here in those words, bad police actions happen because police are human, and subject to human emotions and impulses and undercurrents, that can be shaped by circumstance. The circumstance of good training about crowds and deescalation and all of that (which every good cop knows), the circumstance of poor training, inadequate training, training which is totally inadequate to put these officers in the right kind of relationship with their recently acquired ex-military equipment. Training which the soldiers who originally were meant to handle that equipment had, and overwhelmingly abided by.
We know that not all cops are bastards in the sense that not all cops are awful terrible cunts (although there are one or two, there are a few – look up PC Simon Harwood, go on, look the cunt up). But there is a way in which the office of "cop", simply by way of it being an oppressive apparatus of the state, trails behind it the unwanted, unintended, and yet almost entirely inevitable, office of "bastard". Attached to the coat by rope and strings is this awful thing, this "bastard". It takes work and work and work not to pull the damn thing on. But the length and the strength of the attachment is controlled by two things and two things only. One: the extent to which the officer identifies with an in group and opposes themselves to an out group. Two: the extent to which the operation as an apparatus of the state is oppressive.
The first is modulated by humanity, by human nature, by esprit de corps (which is not only a nice and glorious idea, but a terribly dangerous idea that has people be brutal against one another and can be awakened by the shared endurance of brutality – an efficient method of making people worse by the simple application of violence and fear), by prejudice or to not miss the fucking point the RACISM which is embedded in the structures of your society and mine. The in group. The out group. The us. The them. Him who must be up to something, and him who's probably alright. What a drug mule looks like. What a gangster looks like. What a troublemaker looks like.
The second is modulated by politics, and by the basic fact of the kit which is available. There are circumstances in which heavy duty kit may be necessary, an circumstances in which it isn't. Deploy it where it isn't, in situations which horrify combat vets who have a nodding acquaintance with rules of engagement, and you have already changed not only the circumstances but the human undercurrents and impulses which go with it. Same if you tell them to be tough. They won't ignore you.
It's because the officers are human that we find ourselves in situations where we can't trust them. Society is human. Human nature is what it is. People, given the chance, are bastards. And some people are given the necessary circumstances to be bastards, over and over and over and over again.
says, it's a good thing you were white that night. StoryCorps had a segment this morning about a guy who nearly got shot dead for absolutely no reason, except that he was black and they were white and they could
. For black people, the something has happened in America
is just a continuation of the status quo (although, arguably, things are better now because if the whole nation rises up in protest, the higher-ups will at least look into the case).
This isn't to impugn cops generally, it's just to say that the fact that there are bad apples among them is a matter of deadly concern if you're not white.
… and I hope this doesn't come off as too haranguing or critical. I don't intend criticism; I merely want to register the sense that for people of color, this is the [horrible and wrong] status quo.
|Date:||August 16th, 2014 03:15 am (UTC)|| |
I genuinely feel for your loss of trust. I think the loss of trust or faith in anything that you once believed in is really tough. It always has a lasting effect. I wish I knew what it was like to have something other than fear or hate of cops. I'd love to not feel my body clench up every time I see one. Even as a solidly middle class guy in his mid 40s, that's my almost innate reaction. Down to even my dad's job when I was a kid, I've only ever known that the cops were the ones most likely to bust the heads of people "like us".
This is wonderfully written. I need to come back to it at a time when I can put some thought into a response. All I have to say right now is that Ferguson SUCKED...but it's not fair to bring up the overall LE experience in comparison to this situation. One of the fundamental sore spots for LE is that people do NOT understand what we go through. But Ferguson is not the situation to bring it up and compare it.
The thin blue line exists, don't doubt it. It's there for a good reason, though, and it's not because of situations like Ferguson. It's because of all the times when we do things right and nobody notices or cares. It's because of all the times the bad guys shoot at LE, all the times that LE was right to assume the intent of the actions of that guy (black, white, whatever) on the street corner at 2 am in the vicinity of a recent robbery. All the times that LE goes into a situation genuinely wanting to help someone...and in the blink of an eye it turns deadly. The thin blue line is the people who stand between good and bad. The bond you develop with them is deep, and no one wants to believe that the same person who would have your back in a fire fight could also do something that crosses the line. So you want to protect your own, not because you're bad, yourself, but because you know how close to that line we all can be, sometimes. Not because you're evil but because it's not always black and white. And in the heat of the moment, none of us knows what we would do in that situation. And everyone's an armchair quarterback. And then you feel very isolated and misunderstood.
Anyway...not making excuses for this. Just trying to bring some understanding to a situation where people are mixing up Ferguson with the regular existence of being LE. It's not fair to paint LE with a huge, broad brush...but it is fair to hold bad cops, or bad behavior, up for scrutiny. Every cop and LEO in the nation is feeling harshly uncomfortable right now. Not feeling defensive about Ferguson...but feeling defensive in general. If people could grasp that just a little, it would go a long way toward a mutual understanding.